decide on a treecutting solution #3

New issue

Open

opened 2025-10-14 23:59:57 +00:00 by jlindhardt · 3 comments

jlindhardt commented

2025-10-14 23:59:57 +00:00

Owner

So far, I've tried the following mods:

Lumberjack (semi-hard trees, gravity)
Treecapitator (instant schematic)
Bettertrees (painfully hard trees, sticks, gravity, leaf climbing, leaf regrow, fruit regrow)
Woodcutting (slow schematic)

The ones that use gravity to drop the trees also seem to break leaf decay and more complex tree schematics (eg bettertrees' palms), which is unacceptable. In #12, the modpack under consideration requires bettertrees, and if we go with that one, we'll have to include a dummy bettertrees to satisfy the dependency.

I prefer the slow schematics to instant, it should still take time.

So far, I've tried the following mods: - Lumberjack (semi-hard trees, gravity) - Treecapitator (instant schematic) - Bettertrees (painfully hard trees, sticks, gravity, leaf climbing, leaf regrow, fruit regrow) - Woodcutting (slow schematic) The ones that use gravity to drop the trees also seem to break leaf decay and more complex tree schematics (eg bettertrees' palms), which is unacceptable. In #12, the modpack under consideration requires bettertrees, and if we go with that one, we'll have to include a dummy bettertrees to satisfy the dependency. I prefer the slow schematics to instant, it should still take time.

jlindhardt referenced this issue

2025-10-16 16:19:27 +00:00

Consider the Stone Age Modpack for integration #12

jlindhardt started working

2025-10-18 03:48:57 +00:00

jlindhardt commented

2025-10-18 03:49:24 +00:00

Author

Owner

Simple Woodcutter

Honestly this works pretty well. It did have issues with the giant sequoia but that's literally the biggest one. We'll have to keep testing but this is an excellent candidate.

Would need Hard Trees as well.

# Simple Woodcutter Honestly this works pretty well. It did have issues with the giant sequoia but that's literally the biggest one. We'll have to keep testing but this is an excellent candidate. Would need Hard Trees as well.

jlindhardt canceled time tracking

2025-10-18 13:06:44 +00:00

jlindhardt started working

2025-10-21 00:36:24 +00:00

jlindhardt commented

2025-10-21 00:36:41 +00:00

Author

Owner

Installing Hard Trees now. Let's see if there's anything else we want.

jlindhardt commented

2025-10-21 02:51:43 +00:00

Author

Owner

Actually, do we need hard trees? We can just make the hand tool not break wood. Let's try that first. Yeah okay what we can do is remove level 1 from "oddly_breakable_by_hand" which includes trees. It also seems to include at least the ethereal wood planks, which is fine. This works well and we can not have to worry about another mod.

jlindhardt stopped working

2025-10-21 02:52:13 +00:00

2 hours 15 minutes